Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Thursday, 8th January 2009 Change Date

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Edinburgh Evening News site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Withdraw safety net from banks



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 19 September 2008
AS financial tremors go, the acquisition of Halifax Bank of Scotland by Lloyds TSB this week was about as big an earthquake as you can get on Britain's shores. The scale of any damage is, as yet, unclear – and the aftershock has still to come, but come it will. The biggest losers will be those whose jobs are lost in the next couple of years as the duplicated effort and surplus properties of the combined operations are identified and removed.
Already politicians are scrambling to say what they will do to minimise the impact of the merger – but the fact that HBoS was on the verge of imploding from a crisis of confidence speaks volumes about just how powerless they are when faced with the m
arket.

The Labour Government looks especially helpless. Having needlessly bailed out the badly-managed Northern Rock bank with taxpayers' money to ensure confidence and stability in the financial markets, Alistair Darling and Gordon Brown find they achieved no such thing.

Unable itself to afford the £12 billion that Lloyds TSB is paying for HBoS, the Government could not nationalise again and had no option but to waive the usual rules of competition and allow the new superbank to be formed. Whether such a state of affairs persists in, say, ten years' time when the economic climate might allow the Competition Commission to force a sale of some of the operations, only time will tell.

There will be some that will say we are witnessing a failure of capitalism – but such comments would be absurd as well as wrong. Capitalism requires failure to be punished as much as it requires success to be rewarded.

What we are witnessing is the folly of politicians that say they can end boom and bust, that they can control the outcomes of capitalism and that they can buck the market.

Choosing some banks to save and allowing others to go to the wall – be it here or in the United States – risks creating what is now called moral hazard. In other words protecting people or companies from failure will only encourage them to repeat the mistakes believing that they will not suffer any pain or financial loss.

It's one thing to provide insurance schemes to protect the customers of travel companies or banks from financial ruin, but protect the managers of these companies from losing their jobs – especially when they have been trousering all sorts of bonuses and share schemes in the good years – would be a folly we all would pay for later.

The only way to learn the hard lessons of what is good and bad economic policy is for failure to be allowed to happen so that rebirth takes place and fresh investment follows the success stories.

Time for Tony?

Next week I'm off to the Labour Party conference in Manchester – and the week after that to the Conservative conference in Birmingham – speaking at fringe meetings discussing the nanny state and taking in the atmosphere as party hacks consider their respective parties' prospects.

How different it will be compared to a year ago when Gordon Brown had not long been Prime Minister and was expected to call a general election that most thought he would win.

Now a day doesn't pass without more news about how bad the economy is getting, be it inflation, unemployment, house prices, mortgage lending – you name it. When will the economic news start to get better again?

Probably not for another year – by which point Gordon Brown's time will be nearly up and he won't be able to avoid asking the people to give their verdict.

The man who said he had ended boom and bust is no longer looking quite so clever. If Tony Blair offered to come back and lead the Labour Party I think its MPs would have him back in the blink of an eye – who would have thought that last September?

Broadcast aside

Politicians have lots of ideas about how to spend our money, believing that they can make better decisions for us than we can for ourselves. Gordon Brown is especially adept at this arrogant conceit, but David Cameron has yet to show he's really any different. How refreshing then that Nick Clegg should show that politicians can be different – offering to cut our income tax by 4p. That was to be added to a further 2p tartan tax cut in Scotland being offered by the new Scottish Liberal Democrat leader Tavish Scott.

Wow! That's quite a deal they're offering – what a pity for them then that most people in Britain probably never heard about it.

Thanks to first, the resignation of Scotland Office minister David Cairns, then the auction of Gatwick Airport – and now the purchase of Halifax Bank of Scotland by Lloyds TSB – the Liberal Democrat's conference has hardly figured on the BBC news. Even the publication of this year's Guinness Book of Records was given more coverage!





The full article contains 829 words and appears in Edinburgh Evening News newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 19 September 2008 9:20 AM
  • Source: Edinburgh Evening News
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Brian Monteith
 
1

Proximaking,

Aberdeen 19/09/2008 12:42:51
True capitalism requires infinite resources to prop up the lie that capitalism works, in fact all capitalism does is destroy natural wealth of clean water, unpolluted land etc. Any number of studies have been done to show that capitalism when looked at in the round NEVER has a net benefit. The benefits we have "from capitalism" came instead from people working under a somewhat different creed, usually though not always Christianity. The world can do without a capitalism that requires an infinite resource to plunder as believe it or not we are almost at the end of this planet's tether. The planet will survive a revival of capitalism but we won't. Time to consign it to the dustbin of history. Looks like Adam Smith got his statue on the royal mile just in the nick of time. And to say such thoughts are "absurd" belies a complete failure to comprehend the scale of this ongoing financial disaster. Will the Scotsman survive if its "expert" employees can't see the obvious in front of its face with property prices starting to slide even there. Only Aberdeen will be safe, ..... for a few more months anyway. Talk about a bonfire of the vanities!!
2

A Friend of Fernando Poo,

19/09/2008 12:46:43
#1: Total drivel. Capitalism is what's made us vastly more rich than those countries which practice the weaker and stronger forms of communism.

Monteith is right again. Let the failures go to the wall and the surviving banks takes over their business. This Labour nonsense of punishing thrifty taxpayers to reward reckless bankers is the very opposite of a solution.
3

Unimpressed one,

19/09/2008 13:48:52
With governments having to bail out banks, does this mean we can ask for a windfall tax when the good times return?
4

Joe Smith.,

Moscow 19/09/2008 14:30:01

It's fairly obvious comrade Monteith didn't have his life savings with HBoS or Northern Rock.

The column above is very tenuously informed - a scan of two days' worth of broadsheet front pages and a snap opinion.

The situation is a lot more complex than the writer would have us believe.

5

blackley,

Edinburgh 20/09/2008 12:36:40
So the short-sellers are absolved Mr Monteith? You really are a bit of a scoundrel!
6

david hill,

20/09/2008 21:40:46
There is going to be a world recession no matter how hard of political hierarchy try to stem the tide.

Unfortunately for people throughout the world, Bush and all other leaders et al with their venerable armies of advisers could not see the failings of the market system. Indeed, they worshiped the system like it was a religion. So these same people who are now saying that they will be our saviours and fix the system that they up to two weeks ago adored, are to be expected to make things better. I do not think so and all this is a load of 'hot' air as usual. Things are going to be bad, very bad indeed for quite a few years now (possibly at least a decade) and no matter what these idiots say, I would not believe them if they were the last people living on this planet. Their hypocrisy is without compare.

Considering everything, the capitalist system is totally flawed. Only the few benefit with wealth far in excess of their wildest dreams whilst millions starve to death every year (I thought again that our present leaders were doing something substantial about this awful situation, but I have not heard/seen anything of any major substance yet). Economics has now to change to 'need' economics from the greed economics of the past. If not, the capitalist system will eventually be the end of human life on this planet. It is only a matter of decades and not centuries we are looking at here as natural resources deplete.

Let us hope therefore that the financial collapse of major institutions that exploited/supported past greed to the limits and where the US government is now pumping in at least US1 trillion just to buy the debt that they have created, will make our political masters see the light and that a new dawn has to be forged based upon humanitarian principles and not the planet's destructive forces - super capitalism (globalization).

Next month the World Innovation Foundation's new global economic framework will be outlined in accordance with what is requ
7

david hill,

20/09/2008 21:41:17
continued

Next month the World Innovation Foundation's new global economic framework will be outlined in accordance with what is required by the laws of sustainability and the continuation of the human experience. This outline is being given to Press TV and no other Media source. Therefore if those who wish to know of a new system based on human values and international commerce I would recommend that they visit Press TV around the end of October. It is a totally independent submission based upon the private thinking of many of the world's leading minds.

Dr David Hill
World Innovation Foundation Charity (WIFC)
Bern, Switzerland

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.