Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Wednesday, 19th November 2008 Change Date

Claim a Free Glayva Miniature

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Edinburgh Evening News site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Notorious eyesore flats to come crashing down



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 27 August 2008
ONE of Edinburgh's most notorious eyesores is set to be reduced to rubble within weeks.
Broomview House, in Sighthill, will be given a spectacular send off on September 21.

Around 650 surrounding residents will be forced to find alternative accommodation for the day, as the council have set up an exclusion zone around the condemned b
uilding.

Officials have also warned members of the public to steer clear of the blast zone, and watch the spectacle through a live internet broadcast as there are no safe viewing areas nearby.

The neighbouring Hermiston Court is also due to be brought down soon, although a number of residents are still believed to be occupying some of the flats.

The site – which was home to 84 households but has latterly become a playground for criminals, drug dealing and other antisocial behaviour – will soon be home to a children's playpark and new homes as part of a £60 million-plus redevelopment.

A new street is to be built complete with a parade of shops, a new community centre, library and a student housing development, alongside a new civic space and park.

Despite its bad reputation, former resident Andrew Downie, 62, a semi-retired vehicle mechanic who moved to Broomview House in the mid-70s, remembers the block as a family place.

He met his wife Anne, 66, there and the couple brought up their five children together in a fourth-floor corner flat, where they continued to live until the council moved them out last year.

He said: "The main thing we miss is the view. From our flat we had a great view of the castle, on to Arthur's Seat and beyond, and from another window we could see the Pentlands.

"The place always had a bad reputation but we never had any bother."

In recent years, the building has been sinking into the ground through subsidence.

Mr Downie added: "The ice cream van used to be able to drive through the pillars that support the building, but you couldn't fit a car under there now."

The council has estimated 330 properties will be affected by the exclusion zone.

Margaret Georgeson, 63, a retired Stevenson College cleaner, will have to vacate her Broomhouse Road property for the day.

She said: "A few of my neighbours are disabled and there are some that never leave the house."

City council housing leader Paul Edie called it "a new dawn for housing in Edinburgh".





The full article contains 414 words and appears in Edinburgh Evening News newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 27 August 2008 10:54 AM
  • Source: Edinburgh Evening News
  • Location: Edinburgh
 
1

Grumpy,

27/08/2008 12:14:20
Good news - we get rid of an eyesore building at last. Now all we need o do is get rid of the riff-raff that lurk about the area.

But when do they knock down the next door Napier University building? That will be even more spectacular
2

Alternative (High-Octane) Fuel Head,

Edinburgh 27/08/2008 12:27:49
#1:

They could always invite them into the building to continue their drug dealing etc, just before they hit the button.

Yeah! Man that's great! There's pure no bizzies there now!
3

Howard Moon,

27/08/2008 12:49:42
Sorry grumpy, but the facade of the Napier campus is being retained in the reconstruction I believe. No idea why. Hope that doesn't make you more grumpy.

'Officials have also warned members of the public to steer clear of the blast zone, and watch the spectacle through a live internet broadcast as there are no safe viewing areas nearby.'

No safe areas? They've got that right!

4

jenny,

East Edinburgh 27/08/2008 12:53:33
Any prospect of some allotments in the grand regeneration scheme? Too much to ask for, I guess.
5

Edin,

27/08/2008 12:56:36
I went to that Napier for like a week .. just before the nice new business school was opened at Craiglockhart. it was a dump ! the whole area needs regeneration
6

Franck,

27/08/2008 13:07:56
Jenny,
Why would you want a vegetable patch in Sighthill.

There are vegetables galore walking around that area, you don't need somewhere to bed them down too.
7

Clen Peapus,

Edinburgh 27/08/2008 13:08:58
"I say we take off and nuke the entire site from orbit. It's the only way to be sure."
8

aurorablue,

27/08/2008 13:09:57
You can knock down and rebuild etc but it will be the same old scum that live there.
9

aurorablue,

27/08/2008 13:12:01
Does Sighthill deserve new housing? Six months down the line it will be a graffittid haven for junkies and criminals again.
10

Duncan in Edinburgh,

27/08/2008 13:26:53
There are plenty of decent people who live in Sighthill. You really shouldn't believe the scare stories in the newspapers. Sure, bad things happen, and it's an area of poverty so crimes of poverty are more common than elsewhere. But it is sheer foolishness to dismiss the whole population as "scum" because of what you read in the papers, or have seen on one or two occasions. I've seen soldiers at Redford Barracks behaving like drunken, violent louts but that doesn't make me dismiss teh whole army as scum.
11

Boy Wonder,

27/08/2008 13:28:48
Ever high rise flat in the city should be levelled. They were a busted flush years ago and exist only to breed the worst kind of social problems in the city.

Move all the scum and the lowlifes who infest such areas into the buildings ... and then when they least expect it ... BOOM!!!
12

gorgeousgorgieboy,

Edinburgh 27/08/2008 13:34:27
Once went back there with a burd. Many years ago. Classy wee bitch. The block neasrly came doon that night.
13

AdamKC666,

LV426 27/08/2008 13:46:32
#7 - you don't have the authority to make that kind of decision. You're just a grunt....no offence.
14

Oxgangs Lil,

Edinburgh 27/08/2008 14:22:58
#11

You know it takes all kinds to make a world. What a sad place it would be if all people though like you.
15

,

27/08/2008 14:59:56
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
16

aurorablue,

27/08/2008 15:14:43
#10
'There are plenty of decent people who live in Sighthill. You really shouldn't believe the scare stories in the newspapers' scare stories - terrifying more like. I worked in Sighthill and half of my family live there - I know what it's like there. By the way I consider army types as scum also.
17

Xena - Warrior Princess,

27/08/2008 15:15:36
#11 I believe that has already been done - the Nazis. Not everyone that lives in flats are scum and lowlifes, there a lot of decent people that have no option but to live there.
18

aurorablue,

27/08/2008 15:19:21
#17 no option but to live there - yeah cos they're mostly teenage single mums or folk who won't get a job. They don't have to live there. I work real hard to make money to live somewhere nice - why can't those you speak of do the same?
19

Boy Wonder,

27/08/2008 15:22:40
#17. I didn't say all people in high-rises were scum. I said move the scum IN first before blowing them to smithereens.

And high-rises ARE notorious for the messes they turn into.

Personally, I'd prefer to see high-rises gone and everyone with a house and a garden!
20

Xena - Warrior Princess,

27/08/2008 15:37:13
#18 For such a pretty name you really are a nasty piece of work. I'll go along a wee bit with you on the folk who won't get a job and the teenage single mums but there are also people who work who have to live there. I work hard too and am lucky enough to have a house and a garden but when I started out on my own I lived in a flat and it was the only option at the time. I can't imagine how hard it is for people now to get a decent house as all the good council homes are sold and to even try to buy a house now is out of a lot of people's reach. Boy Wonder I apologise and I agree with you on your preference.
21

fourthletter,

Leith 27/08/2008 15:46:08
How about the banana flats next ? Before the neds down in Leith convince everyone they are part of our culture.
Nice to see Sighthill being sorted out though, I'm sure that alot of people who live there are very nice but having visited friends there is realy is a stinking mess, about time someone lanced that boil.

Why does everyone in Edinburgh think having an allotment is part of their human rights ? Buy a house with a bigger garden or rent some land, Don't waste my tax money on vegtables I don't get to eat.
22

aurorablue,

27/08/2008 15:46:33
#20 - It is a pretty name isn't it! I am however not a nasty piece of work - i leave that for those who live in highrises in Sighthill!
23

J4cko,

27/08/2008 16:03:51
Knocking down houses and flats leads to a shortage of council housing due to all the people who need to be re-housed.

You have junkies and general low lives but you also get decent hard working people living in the poorer areas too. I live in a particulary bad area but I am not on benifits, I work hard and I am trying to get my own house.

These people that say "work harder and get a decent house somewhere nice" - what a joke!! Not all people can afford a nice house with a garden in a nice wee area no matter how hard you try.

The sweeping generalisation of people just because they live in a flat is unbelievable!
24

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 27/08/2008 16:11:12

No we are not "Scum" and some like my DYW works hard for a living, we do NOT do "Drugs"

Please STOP the 'stereotyping'!
25

Xena - Warrior Princess,

27/08/2008 16:21:15
#23 and 24 spot on do you not think aurorablue sounds awfy like "allknowing"?
26

aurorablue,

27/08/2008 16:23:07
#25 - that's quite an accurate description actually, well done!
27

Mr Fuzzy,

Edinburgh 27/08/2008 16:33:04
I've see the buildings from the bus - they didn't look that bad, and they must have had panoramic views of the city, especially for time-lapse photography (clouds rolling in, sunsets, sunrises).

But they did seem rather isolated from the rest of the city - not even a pub, restaurant, supermarket or fitness centre like apartment blocks have in Canada.
28

elayne,

27/08/2008 17:57:15
these flats were modern and sought after in the 60s and 70s,although it has been said they looked ugly,question?WHY built multis on ground that is subsiding?,the flats had a good innings but outlived thier use as few want to live in high rise blocks nowadays,great veiws for top flats though!(visited someone in top flat years ago and was impressed with the panoramic veiw)
29

allknowing,

27/08/2008 19:12:54
#25

gee thanks, good to know i am missd.

Personally, i will be glad to see them gone. As above, not all are scum, but they have more than their faie share down that way. But, whats the point of spending ££££, if the same scum are still there. I give it 12 months and it will revert back to a ghetto!
30

elayne,

27/08/2008 19:28:15
#29 hopefully it will be a better social mix in the new houses,i am not sure if it is mid rent homes,housing assoc or whatever,there are a lot of nice folk in sighthill but it gained a reputation due to the council in their wisdom housing a few undesirables in the area(as they are apt to do)i know someone who lived in the flats when they were first built and she loved it(this was in 1960s or 70s)but times and peoples needs change
31

Statsman,

Edinburgh 27/08/2008 20:12:03
Darn. I was hoping the article title referred to Platinum Point.
32

pofi,

27/08/2008 22:30:13
Nice one #21, I like your style!! "One couldn't possibly plant vegetables in one's own garden, what would the neighbours say?!"
The land vacated by the high rises will have to be developed to rebuild the same number of flats; every inch will be accounted for to accomodate that.
New social housing is a priority in this city- no matter how long the waiting list is for allotments it's hardly a social disaster. Homelessness is!
33

Gina Gibson,

Wales 27/08/2008 23:40:27
If they blow those flats up then where are all the drunks going to urinate on their way back from the Shighthill Inn?
34

TheSmith,

28/08/2008 10:45:06
Do any of you people actually know any Sighthill residents?
35

former occupant,

Edinburgh 02/09/2008 16:35:37
I lived in Broonview House for nine years and I am not a junkie, a drunk nor am I anti-social.
Your right there were great views of the castle and neighbouring hills, fantastic at New Year with the fireworks.
Even though Broomview comes under Sighthill it is on the other side of the main road of the private houses in Sighthill. Broonview House is closer to Broomhouse than Sighthill.
I hope that the new houses that will be built won't just be for students and are council houses as I have put my name down to come back to the area. unless you have actually lived in this area and in Broomview then you don't know what it is like to stay here and comments on heresay is counter productive. No area is fantastic there are undesireables in most areas due to private lets so don't judge a book by its cover. There are a lot of decent people who live in Sighthill and surrounding areas.
36

kaci,

edinburgh 13/09/2008 21:13:07
does any1 know what time on the 21st the button is getting pressed? and what website its showing live?

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.