Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Wednesday, 7th January 2009 Change Date

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Edinburgh Evening News site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Primary pupils go top of the class in three Rs



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 30 October 2008
PUPILS have achieved record results in the three Rs at the Capital's primary schools. Youngsters posted the best results on record this year after the vast majority passed literacy and numeracy tests with flying colours.
Education leaders today praised the hard work of children and teachers as well as efforts to spread best practice to all city schools.

There has been a dramatic turn around at some schools in recent years.

At Niddrie Mill Primary for instance,
only a third of pupils passed their maths tests in 2003, but now almost three-quarters are up to speed. The school has also seen similar improvements in reading, and, to a slightly lesser extent, in writing.

At St Catherine's RC Primary in Gracemount, three-quarters of children now pass their maths tests, with pupils also achieving dramatically improved pass rates in reading and writing. Six years ago, less than half the children there passed in each of the three Rs.

There has been much less clear change at the higher end, where some schools were already achieving almost perfect pass rates in 2002.

But concerns have been raised about the high numbers of children still leaving primary school without the basic skills.

A third of pupils across the primary school age range failed their tests in reading, writing or maths in 2008, while just over a quarter of schools are still struggling to meet the minimum levels.

And in one in ten schools – including the closure-threatened Westburn Primary – a third of all pupils are failing to meet the basic standards in all of the three Rs.

The results are contained in a newly published report which shows gradual progress has been made over the past six years in raising core skills.

The lessons learned at schools which made the biggest improvements are now to be passed on to teachers across the city.

Councillor Marilyne MacLaren, the city's education leader, said: "This is testament to a great deal of hard work by teachers and pupils alike. However, it is important we do not become complacent, as there is still a lot of work to be done for under-achieving children to narrow the divide between the highest and lowest achievers.

"Officers look at schools where attainment figures have improved markedly to learn from them and then apply the good practice to schools across the city."

The top performing school is St Peter's Primary in Morningside, where 98 per cent of pupils have met or exceeded minimum standards in reading and 96 per cent in writing.

At Bonaly Primary School, 98 per cent of pupils gained the basic maths skills, making it the top performer in that subject.

On average, pupils in Edinburgh's primaries are performing well, comfortably meeting the nationally-set minimum standards. A total of 84 per cent of pupils are achieving or exceeding the basics in reading and maths – both up from 82 per cent last year – while 77 per cent of children are making the grade in writing, which is also a two per cent rise from 2007.

Among the schools expected to receive extra support are Royston Primary and the closure-threatened Lismore and Westburn primaries, which have the worst results for maths, writing and reading respectively.

Councillor Ricky Henderson, Labour's education spokesman, said he was concerned about the attainment gap between the better performing schools and some of the others.

He said: "The general improvement is to be welcomed. However, there is still a concerning disparity between the better performing schools and the poorer ones.

"I'm not a great fan of league tables because they don't reflect all the things that go on in a school, but obviously you want children to be able to read and write before they go to secondary school."

The improving primary school results follows other good news from the Capital's schools.

The number of high school pupils who are achieving good grades in their exams is also on the increase, with students in the Capital outperforming the Scottish average in the Higher exams sat in May.

The number of pupils who got good Standard Grade results is also higher than it has been for the past six years. The number of Higher passes among fifth year pupils has risen by more than 250, while those gaining three or more Highers has risen by two per cent. In addition, 19 out of the city's 23 high schools have seen an increase in the number of pupils passing at least three Highers between 2006-07 and 2007-08.





The full article contains 765 words and appears in Edinburgh Evening News newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 30 October 2008 10:40 AM
  • Source: Edinburgh Evening News
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Schools in Edinburgh
 
1

JayDeeTee,

30/10/2008 12:40:00
Amazing. An article about school exam results written by a woman that does not crow about how much better girls are doing. Surely it needs to be re-edited.
2

Vincent-W,

30/10/2008 12:44:01
Be very careful - this apparent improvement is often a sham caused by the pressure put on teachers to submit kids for tests before they are fully competent to boost their schools attainment figures.

I know of area managers in the primary sector pressurising heads to submit kids for these tests too early.

The only consequence is that the kids are not properly grounded, and instead of going to High School with a solid D level in maths, they are going with a dodgy E level.

Beware this is a major problem in our schools and will cause incredible problems later on.

I am lucky my kids school is resisting these pressures and my kids go to HS performing better in maths than kids from other schools with apparently higher attainment.

THIS PRACTICE MUST BE STOPPED!!!
3

Hmm?,

30/10/2008 12:46:21
"PUPILS have achieved record results in the three Rs at the Capital's primary schools."

and

"A third of pupils across the primary school age range failed their tests in reading, writing or maths in 2008, while just over a quarter of schools are still struggling to meet the minimum levels.

And in one in ten schools – including the closure-threatened Westburn Primary – a third of all pupils are failing to meet the basic standards in all of the three Rs."

So, are they doing brilliantly or not? Confused?
4

alex paterson,

edinburgh 30/10/2008 12:49:49
Me thinks tests or exams are getting easier for the kids than ever before.
5

Vincent-W,

30/10/2008 12:56:45
alex paterson,

no you're wrong, but the pass mark is very low and the marking system is partially subjective.

The result is teachers know that their pupils need a good high mark to proceed with confidence to more complex problems.

Problem is teachers are being pressured to put kids in for the test prmaturely, the kids pass with lower marks but do not fully understand the subject before being asked to build on their learning.

The problem is that, it is frequently parents demanding better results without really understanding the consequences of driving for higher attainment.

They do not really understand the way the system is being used to distort real progress.
6

contradiction,

in the naughty corner 30/10/2008 13:06:03
why doesn't the council just close the poorer performing schools ? that would massage the figures upwards.

Oh .... they're already doing that.
7

Vincent-W,

30/10/2008 13:06:11
The 5 to 14 guidelines are a good system used properly. But attainment levels are being politicized by ambitious managers, headteachers and parents.

This is not benefitting the pupils.

The 5 - 15 idea was and is good - when applied properly and not used as a political football.
8

Vincent-W,

30/10/2008 13:07:45
C'mon Crubag - where are you when you're needed?
9

Boy Wonder,

30/10/2008 13:24:01
We got the three "R"s in school today
But two start with "A" and with "W"
It's not the pupils who get it wrong
But the teachers who try to befuddle you!!

c 1984
10

Top Floor,

in the naughty corner 30/10/2008 14:41:11
It can never be acceptable to allow children in our schools to under achieve. I do hope our Council are not being complacent about their responsibilities.
11

alex paterson,

edinburgh 30/10/2008 14:55:36
#5
Funny that,a couple of years ago school pupils of today were given our test papers for the Qualy and they all failed.
12

gorgeousgorgieboy,

Edinburgh 30/10/2008 15:27:14
When i was in Primary 7 i could spell antidisestablishmentarianism.

Dont know if I still can.
13

Slobberchops the Aesthete,

30/10/2008 15:37:07
dont B so neggative evryone. "Well dun" 2 orl puppils!
14

Andrew,

30/10/2008 17:17:22
Reading, respect, results?
15

Hector101,

30/10/2008 17:19:48
And, of course, one of the reasons schools are under pressure to get primary pupils through National Assessments is because the EN publish unofficial league tables.
Teachers are having to spend more and more time getting children through these assessments, at the expense of other areas of the curriculum and steady, structured learning, in order that politicians and their officials can convince the electorate that they are improving educational standards.
It is only when pupils move classes and schools that it becomes glaringly obvious that many are not performing securely at the assessed level.
This, unfortunately, is the price they pay in a target driven society where the main aim is to make things look good on paper.
16

silent majority,

edinburgh 30/10/2008 17:30:16
The usual guff from Alex Paterson about "exams getting easier". No doubt he was taught in a class of +40 pupils by an unqualified and unregistered teacher where everything was so much better...I think not.
How about recognising the fact that many of our young people are motivated to learn, are better taught (by professionally qualified staff)and, in the main, are in reasonable class sizes. Remember that this generation of young people who, allegedly can only pass much easier exams than yesteryear, are tomorrow's doctors, engineers, solicitors and so on....
Rather than constantly put our young people down, why not praise achievement?
17

Vincent-W,

30/10/2008 19:27:55
alex paterson - you are showing your ignorance. The "Qualy" and the grades in the 5 - 14 guidelines are as different as chalk and cheese.

The 5-14 guidelines are a very good set of papers as they are designed as a flexible system to suit each individual child and at the same time give a framework for teachers to work around. And many PS teachers are comfortable working with them.

The problem is that other adults mess the system up. Parents, wrongly, apply pressure to teachers to push "wee Fiona or Hamish" through a grade before they are ready. As if having a 'C' first is important! Line managers pressure heads to "improve performance", like getting an 11 year old to do what a 13 year old should do. And politicians apply general pressure to te system to prove that the SNP/Labour/Lib Dems deliver better results.

The fact is that the system is flexible and therefore prone to abuse. I have seen kids coming from some PS with a solid 'D' from one school, way ahead in maths of a child with a shaky 'E' from another PS.

I say:- leave the teachers to deliver teaching to a high standard to our marvellous kids according to the excellent 5-14 guidelines. Everyone else - BUTT OUT!!!
18

alex paterson,

edinburgh 30/10/2008 20:34:43
#17
The point i was making is the kids today are a bit thicker than our generation,primary or secondary.
19

Vincent-W,

30/10/2008 21:53:53
alex (sic),

Rubbish, my boys are way ahead of me at the same age.

Against you, they would be breasting the tape before you were out of the blocks.

I will agree that in terms of some measuring systems there are differences. But to say that children today are 'thicker' is ludicrous.

Where on the spectrum did you say you were?

ps - first person singular pronouns are written with capital letters, as do proper nouns. Even my six year old knows that!
20

Evia,

30/10/2008 22:17:56
Education has certainly been dumbed down and as long as pupils can read and write benefits, they should be OK. This is the reason that some of us do without much in order to send our children to private schools or educate them at home.
21

Enrich,

Edinburgh 31/10/2008 20:10:35
"The results are contained in a newly published report which shows gradual progress has been made over the past six years in raising core skills."

Who published/wrote the report? Where can we read it for ourselves?
22

Spathiphyllum,

12/12/2008 14:59:47
What I've noticed in recent times, working alongside young people who recently left school, is that they cannot do joined up writing.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.